The hierarchy of reinforcement is also referred to as establishing operations. Hierarchy runs in two directions positive and negative reinforcers. At the top of the list on the positive side is the reward. Punishment is at the top of the list on the negative side. All others are simply reinforcers either positive or negative. For our purposes we will deal with the positive hierarchy.
First identify all things the dog seems to like, ball, kong, tug, squeaky toy, food treats, and any other positive reinforcer you can manage. Your dog may really like to chase live prey and if you could use it that reinforcer would be at the top of the list. However this is not a practical, and could be very dangerous.
To identify the reinforcers that stimulate your dog’s prey instincs hold the dog while all the toys are tossed in front of the dog a few feet away. Let the dog go and do not influence its decision in any way. The dog may move from one to the next picking up one or more and then dropping them for another. This process can continue for several minutes. Once the dog has decided it will focus on that toy. It may occasionally grab another but it will immediately refocus on the one it has chosen.
Now that the dog has chosen its reward of the group we will ask the dog if it will give it up for food. If the dog gives up the toy eagerly for food the dog’s reward may be food. The dog’s behavior after receiving the food will provide the clues. Should the dog leave the toy and focus only on the possibility of receiving food then food is the reward. However if the dog quickly grabs the food and refocuses on the toy the toy is the highest. In human terms we could call the dog greedy. For training this is a good thing. It allows you to use a host of different reinforcers. The value of this will be discussed in more detail during schedules of reinforcement.